Home & Garden

Canadian Peat Harvest Variance Points Growers Toward a More Flexible Growing-Media Strategy

A CSPMA extraction report shows wide regional differences, but the deeper message is that raw-material sourcing is becoming a risk-management decision.

Ayesha SiddiquiOctober 12, 20265 min read5 views
An illustrated greenhouse bench holds separate piles of growing-media materials such as peat and coir, with a gloved hand comparing textures beside trays of young seedlings in soft daylight.

The Canadian Sphagnum Peat Moss Association's Sept. 17 report, covering conditions through Aug. 31, gives growers a supply signal that is uneven rather than alarming. Regional extraction rates diverged sharply: Alberta reached 56% of expected extraction, Manitoba 79%, Saskatchewan 90%, Québec's North and South Shores 77%, Southern New Brunswick 70%, Northern New Brunswick 85%, and Ontario 90%. Prince Edward Island, Newfoundland and Labrador, and Nova Scotia were reported as significantly below expected levels.

CSPMA attributes much of the shortfall to wet weather and states that careful inventory management should allow producers to meet customer needs. Writing for Greenhouse Grower, Jennifer Neujahr, former Director of Horticulture Business for Profile Products and co-founder of Next Step Solutions, argues this is not a call to declare a peat shortage. Instead, she treats it as a reminder that an agricultural raw material harvested outdoors will never be fully insulated from weather.

Expected extraction is not a harvest total

Neujahr stresses that CSPMA's "expected extraction" is not a measure of how much available peatland was harvested. It is the amount producers calculated they needed for the season: market requirements plus the desired year-end inventory buffer, minus inventory carried into 2026. That framing shifts the useful question for growers away from whether they will run out of peat toward how resilient their growing-media strategy is when a material they depend on becomes harder or more expensive to secure.

The risk is wider than one input

Peat sits inside a broader supply picture. Climate affects harvest and biomass availability, while labor affects harvesting, processing, and transportation. Freight, Neujahr notes, can change the economics of a material long before its FOB price moves. She cites a late-September Wall Street Journal report that U.S. contract trucking rates averaged $3.11 per mile in August, including fuel surcharges, up 29% from a year earlier. Diesel, driver availability, rail surcharges, and ocean freight all add volatility, and for a bulky input such as growing media, delivered cost can change a sourcing decision quickly.

She also points to economist Dr. Charlie Hall, who has emphasized supply-chain agility, backup suppliers, and working-capital discipline as growers plan for 2027. Hall's Index of Prices Paid by Growers is useful, Neujahr writes, because the cheapest input on paper is not necessarily the lowest-risk or lowest-cost decision once freight, inventory, and operational impacts are included. Her conclusion is that raw-material selection should stop being a once-a-year purchasing exercise and start being a risk-management and production-design decision.

Start with the crop, then choose ingredients

Neujahr argues the industry often builds growing media in the wrong direction — starting from whatever is available, such as peat, coir, bark, wood fiber, or perlite, and constructing a mix around those ingredients. A better starting point, she says, is the crop: how much water holding and air porosity the root zone needs, how much structural stability is required through the cycle, how the material must rewet, what buffering and chemistry the crop and irrigation program can tolerate, and how uniform it must be for automation. Only then should growers back into the ingredients and percentages that create that character.

The raw-material toolbox is expanding. Wageningen University & Research's 2026 work on the future of growing media identifies market-accepted materials such as coir, coniferous wood fiber, bark, compost, and perlite, alongside less familiar candidates including other plant fibers, biochars, co-composts, and reused growing media. The researchers note that many new materials require processing, sanitization, and stabilization before they become reliable horticultural inputs. Availability, Neujahr adds, is not the same as suitability — but suitability is increasingly something that can be engineered.

Revisit old decisions, and consider small inclusions

Processing technology has improved across coir, wood fiber, bark, and other biomass streams, so materials that were once too inconsistent, wet, coarse, salty, or expensive may deserve another look. Neujahr is not suggesting growers abandon proven substrates; she argues they should know what else exists before they need it. A new component also does not have to dominate a formulation. In some systems, a 5% or 10% inclusion may be enough to shift cost, water behavior, structure, rewetting, or supply exposure. The right rate is a crop-and-system question, and any new component needs to be trialed and validated before commercial adoption.

This is where small trials become strategic, she writes: trial an alternative wood fiber, reconsider rice hulls, bark fractions, coir products, or locally available biomass, and understand what changes in irrigation, fertility, handling, and crop performance.

Local and global are not either/or

Sourcing closer to home can reduce transportation exposure, but Neujahr cautions that local is not automatically better, just as imported is not automatically risky. Coir travels long distances yet can offer characteristics difficult to reproduce with some local materials; peat remains an extraordinarily important and effective component; wood fiber and bark can contribute well where feedstock and processing are right. The more resilient strategy, she suggests, is a portfolio: dependable core materials, strong supplier relationships, some regional options, some globally sourced options, and enough formulation knowledge to adjust without losing the root-zone character the crop requires.

Use 2026 as a planning signal

The lesson is not that growers should move away from peat. CSPMA itself says inventory management should allow producers to meet customer requirements. The lesson, per Neujahr, is that the conditions behind raw materials can change quickly while crops still have to be produced on schedule. Growing-media demand is also rising: Wageningen research projects global demand increasing substantially toward 2050, implying a need for a broader basket of materials and more processing capacity rather than a single winner in the peat-versus-coir-versus-wood-fiber debate.

For growers planning 2027, she recommends asking which raw materials are most exposed in current formulations, what their true delivered cost is, which characteristics are essential to the crop, what other ingredients could deliver part of that function, and which should be trialed now. The best time to build flexibility into a growing-media program, she concludes, is while choices still exist.